Ur Dawkins Dimbleby Lecture, BBC1 TV , Nov 12, 96.
...
Here's a small sample of the things you could tell Aristotle, or any other Greek philosopher. And surprise and enthral them,
not just with the facts themselves but with how they hang together so elegantly.
The earth is not the centre of the universe. It orbits the sun - which is just another star. There is no music of the spheres, but
the chemical elements, from which all matter is made, arrange themselves cyclically, in something like octaves. There are not
four elements but about 100. Earth, air, fire and water are not among them.
Living species are not isolated types with unchanging essences. Instead, over a time scale too long for humans to imagine, they
split and diverge into new species, which then go on diverging further and further. For the first half of geological time our
ancestors were bacteria. Most creatures still are bacteria, and each one of our trillions of cells is a colony of bacteria. Aristotle
was a distant cousin to a squid, a closer cousin to a monkey, a closer cousin still to an ape (strictly speaking, Aristotle was an ape,
an African ape, a closer cousin to a chimpanzee than a chimp is to an orang utan).
The brain is not for cooling the blood. It's what you use to do your logic and your metaphysics. It's a three dimensional maze of
a million million nerve cells, each one drawn out like a wire to carry pulsed messages. If you laid all your brain cells end to end,
they'd stretch round the world 25 times. There are about 4 million million connections in the tiny brain of a chaffinch,
proportionately more in ours.
Now, if you're anything like me, you'll have mixed feelings about that recitation. On the one hand, pride in what Aristotle's
species now knows and didn't then. On the other hand an uneasy feeling of, "Isn't it all a bit complacent? What about our
descendants, what will they be able to tell us?"
Yes, for sure, the process of accumulation doesn't stop with us. 2000 years hence, ordinary people who have read a couple of
books will be in a position to give a tutorial to today's Aristotles: to Francis Crick, say, or Stephen Hawking. So does this mean
that our view of the universe will turn out to be just as wrong?
...
|